Very short review:
This is how shooting a Coonan Arms makes you feel:
Longer review:
Indy Trading Post has a Coonan Arms .357 magnum in their rental cabinet. It's the most fun you can have for $12 outside of Thailand.
Here is it:
It's bigger than a 1911, of course. The grip is long but relatively thin, and feels right. After shooting it, everything else just felt small in my hands. (Keep your minds out of the gutter.) The trigger is not a true 1911 trigger where it pushes straight back, it is more like a single action revolver hinged at the top. It is light, crisp, and predictable. I was immediately a fan after dry firing.
The magazine springs are TOUGH. The mags are designed with discs on the side to help push the follower down to fully load the mags. 5 rounds insert easily without using the disc. Rounds 6 and 7 required the use of the discs. Round 8 required using the disc, holding your mouth just right, and an appropriate grunt. Fully loaded with 8:
I loaded up 7 rounds (didn't know the appropriate grunt yet) and fired at a 1" bull's eye target at 7 yards.
You will note 6 very nice shots...and one keyhole. It was the last shot and it felt odd when it fired. Almost like a "catch" occurred, for lack of better terms. It never happened again and I'm going to blame the ammo on that one. Geco .357, for the record. So, after discovering the gun shoots about as well as anything in my hands, it was time to speed up a bit. After a total of 30 rounds, the target looked like this:
Other than the keyhole and one called flier, everything is grouped pretty nicely. Each square is 1"x1". I sped up until I started creeping left, then slowed back down. You can't shoot it quite as fast as a .45 1911, but the recoil was less than I expected and it settled back in pointing naturally and wasn't tough on the hands at all.
For comparison, I ran 20 rounds through my GP100 Match Champion at the same distance.
The first cylinder was low and left. The grip felt small in my hand and the recoil difference was immediately noticeable. In fact, I'd say I preferred the Coonan in terms of feel and recoil management. Single action trigger is a wash, both are very nice. Sights are also preference. The GP100's fiber optics vs the bright white dot of the Coonan. After re-acclimating to the GP100 I was back on target with it, and it's tough to say which is more accurate, but the Coonan is easier to be accurate with faster.
All said, I'm not sure I'd pay the money to BUY a Coonan, but I'd definitely RENT it again. It was a lot of fun, it shoots well, its not punishing (but it is loud)...but given the size I think it's mostly a range toy. Not that you couldn't carry it if you put your mind to it, I just think the bulk and length would make it less than ideal for me.